# A perfect record and an empty exit: Kamino vaults read two ways

> 31 Kamino Earn vaults read two ways: 30 of 31 never dropped on our record, yet three holding $116M had almost nothing withdrawable on Nov 18. With AtlasYield.

Canonical: https://tradingagentstack.com/research/kamino-vaults-two-ways/

1. [Home](https://tradingagentstack.com/)

2. [Research](https://tradingagentstack.com/research/broker-mcp-order-gating/)

3. Kamino vaults read two ways

# A perfect record and an empty exit: 31 Kamino vaults read two ways

By Ahsen (TradingAgentStack) with Jeevesh Kuril ([AtlasYield](https://atlasyield.club/), [@atlasyieldc](https://x.com/atlasyieldc)) · published Nov 21, 2026 · figures as of Nov 18, 2026

On Nov 18, three Kamino Earn vaults holding $116M between them had never fallen in value on our record, and almost none of that money could be withdrawn. Nothing went wrong in them. Their money was lent out, so a depositor who wanted out that day would have had to wait.

We read 31 Kamino Earn vaults two ways. TradingAgentStack measures what each vault's share price actually did. AtlasYield scores what a depositor is exposed to, including whether they can get out. On 30 of the 31 our record shows no drop at all, and the last one, Galaxy USDT, dipped less than 0.01%, so the share price alone can't tell them apart. The exit read can.
**31**Kamino Earn vaults read both ways
**30 of 31**with no drop on our record
**$116M**in three vaults with almost nothing withdrawable on Nov 18

## Two ways to read a vault

A Kamino Earn vault takes one token, such as USDC, and a curator lends it across Kamino's markets. The two readings answer different questions.

|  | TradingAgentStack | AtlasYield |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Question | What did the vault actually return, and how far did it fall? | What is a depositor exposed to before they go in? |
| Built from | Kamino's published share-price history, up to the last year | 16 parameters in four pillars (yield, safety, liquidity, sustainability), rescored every 4 hours |
| Catches | Losses that already happened | Risks that haven't shown up in the price yet, such as a vault you can't exit |
| Leaves to the other | Risk that hasn't hit the share price yet | The return the vault actually delivered over the past year |

A lending vault's share price mostly falls when a loan goes bad or something breaks, so a clean record can hide a vault that is fully lent out. That's the gap this piece is about.

## Where the two readings disagree

Three vaults have a spotless record on our side and the lowest AtlasYield scores in the set, all because of exit liquidity.

| Vault | Size | Our record | Yearly rate | Worst drop | AtlasYield score | Withdrawable at the Nov 18 read |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **wYLDS Allocator** [our record](https://tradingagentstack.com/kamino-earn-vaults/#vaults) · [AtlasYield](https://atlasyield.club/vaults/kamino/792703809/cwptesngaxj8s3arsfhtuomb5zqaa1tmjbykqvljjxmd) | $62.9M | 59 days | 4.74% | 0.00% | 44.7 (Aggressive) | 0% ($0 of $62.9M) |
| **Ethena PYUSD Prime** [our record](https://tradingagentstack.com/kamino-earn-vaults/#vaults) · [AtlasYield](https://atlasyield.club/vaults/kamino/792703809/4twka9jxegelepaploarhsqoqwoiu12dkdcjsuvvhquf) | $3.8M | 168 days | 2.80% | 0.00% | 45.3 (Aggressive) | 1.9% |
| **Kamino Institutional Commodity Yield** [our record](https://tradingagentstack.com/kamino-earn-vaults/#vaults) · [AtlasYield](https://atlasyield.club/vaults/kamino/792703809/b5pjfzaikjyueuqb2694nhrsjcam67uujawqjztvtzr6) | $49.6M | 111 days | 7.81% | 0.00% | 51.6 (Aggressive) | 0% |

In all three the lending markets were 98 to 100% used. The money was earning, which is why the share price looked perfect, and it was out on loan, which is why it couldn't leave. That is normal for a lending vault for a while. The risk is what happens if borrowers don't repay before depositors need their money back.

## Paid more, and the cost shows in the exit

Kamino Private Credit USDC is where the two readings come closest to telling the same story, from different sides. Its record starts on Mar 13, the first day it held $1,000, and shows no drop since: 7.22% a year over 250 days, the second-highest yearly rate in the set after Institutional Commodity Yield. AtlasYield scores it 61.6 (Balanced), with 6.1% withdrawable and its market 96% used. It pays more, and the cost shows only in the exit read.

## How the exit read works

AtlasYield checks how much of each vault can be withdrawn on every scoring run, every 4 hours. The score uses the lower of two medians: the last 3 reads (about 12 hours) and the last 6 (about 24 hours). One busy hour can't sink a vault, two stressed reads in a row will, and a recovery has to hold about 12 hours before the score lifts.

Kamino Institutional Commodity Yield shows how it moves. It scored 63.5 in the 00:03 UTC run on Nov 18 and 51.6 by 17:27 UTC, after at least two of its last three reads showed nothing free to withdraw.

Two things to know when reading the numbers. Withdrawable is capped at the vault's own size, so a small vault can show 100% withdrawable while its market is 80 to 90% lent out. Utilization is the market-wide reading.

## Three things that look like data but aren't

**The 69s are a cap, not a measurement.** Seven vaults score exactly 69. Five have a single admin key and two have an admin AtlasYield can't read, and AtlasYield caps any such vault at 69. Without the cap these seven would have scored about 71 to 76.

**Part of some APYs is rewards, not the share price.** Kamino quotes Sentora PYUSD at 6.76%, while its share price grew 2.67% over the year; by AtlasYield's read, 52% of its 7.5% APY is paid as rewards, leaving a base rate of 3.6%. Plume x Re7 USDC is quoted at 8.75% against 3.18% a year in the share price since Sep 1, with 33% from rewards. Rewards explain part of each gap, not all of it. Our record only sees the share price, so rewards paid outside the vault don't show in it.

**Echlon Optimized USDC's +47.8% wasn't lending interest.** Kamino's history shows tokens per share jumping 43.6% on May 2, 2026, while the vault held $15 to $205. That fits tokens sent straight into a near-empty vault. From May 14, the first day it held over $1,000, it returned 2.8% in 188 days, about 5.5% a year and in line with its peers. Our record for it now starts on May 14, under the same $1,000 rule every vault follows.

## What a depositor should take from it

- **A record with no drops isn't the same as an easy exit.** For a lending vault, check how much you could withdraw today, not only how the share price behaved.

- **Check the share-price return against the quoted APY.** When they differ by a lot, find out how much of the APY is rewards and how they're paid.

- **Look behind a round score.** A score of exactly 69 on AtlasYield is usually an admin cap; the vault page says when one applies.

- **A sudden jump in a small vault deserves a question before it earns a rank.**

This isn't a warning about any one vault. The point is that one number can't show everything, and the two readings together show more than either alone.

## Method and sources

- **Vaults:** the 31 Kamino Earn vaults over $250K that both sites cover, on Nov 18, 2026.

- **TradingAgentStack record:** return, yearly rate and worst drop computed from Kamino's published share-price history, at most the last year, after the vault's own fees. A vault's record starts on the first day it held $1,000 or more, so tokens sent into a nearly empty vault don't count as return. Rewards paid outside the vault aren't included. Data as of Nov 18, 2026. [Kamino Earn vaults on TradingAgentStack](https://tradingagentstack.com/kamino-earn-vaults/)

- **AtlasYield score:** composite, pillars, caps and exit liquidity from AtlasYield's live scoring run, Nov 18, 2026 at 17:27 UTC, scorer version 2.4.0. AtlasYield rescores every 4 hours, six runs a day. Its public GitHub snapshot (CC BY 4.0) stores one run per day, the one just after midnight UTC, with every vault's score and pillar scores plus route checks, admin data and alerts. The five runs in between, including the 17:27 run used here, are served by the live API but not committed to GitHub. [AtlasYield](https://atlasyield.club/) ([@atlasyieldc](https://x.com/atlasyieldc))

- **Not advice:** research and information, not investment advice.

The vault-by-vault record is on [Kamino Earn vaults](https://tradingagentstack.com/kamino-earn-vaults/); each vault's AtlasYield score and pillars are on [atlasyield.club](https://atlasyield.club/). Found something that looks wrong? [Tell us](https://tradingagentstack.com/submit/).

## For agents

- [When to use this site, and the page index](https://tradingagentstack.com/llms.txt)
- [Sitemap](https://tradingagentstack.com/sitemap.xml)
- [Contact](https://tradingagentstack.com/contact/)
- [MCP server](https://tradingagentstack.com/mcp/)
- [MCP discovery](https://tradingagentstack.com/.well-known/mcp)
